The cheapest loan can leave you $80,000 short of the house

From the Healthy Wealthy Investor newsletter, edition 33, first sent 16 October 2026. Expanded for the web.

It was a Wednesday morning at my desk in Perth. I was reading the coverage of a new ASIC report on mortgage brokers. It had come out the day before.

Most people want one thing from a broker. Find me the cheapest rate.

ASIC wanted much the same. A good broker sector, it said, matches people with loans that fit their needs “at the lowest available cost for given features” [1].

So here’s the catch. Measure cost over five years, on loans that do the same job, and the cheapest rate and the cheapest outcome can be two different loans. The cheaper rate can come from a lender who lends you far less.

What ASIC looked at in Report 840

Since 1 January 2021, the law has required mortgage brokers to act in your best interests [2]. That’s the best interests duty.

ASIC’s Report 840 came out on Tuesday 13 October 2026. It checked how brokers were meeting that duty [1].

It covered 13 credit licensees, the firms brokers work under. They sit in eight large aggregator groups, which together hold about two-thirds of all broker representatives [1].

ASIC went back through 1,600 loan recommendations. They were written between 1 April 2023 and 31 March 2025 [1].

Most licensees costed a loan over its full term, usually 30 years. A few used five years. Five years is closer to how long people keep a loan before they sell or refinance.

So ASIC turned every 30-year cost into a five-year one. It divided it by six [1].

What ASIC found

Seven of the eight groups reported that, in more than one case in five, their brokers recommended a loan other than the cheapest on the shortlist [1].

On its own, that figure proves nothing either way. What matters is whether the reason is on file, and whether it holds up.

Brokers gave familiar reasons. An offset account or redraw. A fast approval to meet a settlement date. And in ASIC’s words, “serviceability considerations to improve borrowing capacity” [1].

Serviceability is the bank’s sum on whether your income covers the repayments. Borrowing capacity is how much that sum lets you borrow.

ASIC then graded the written reason on 551 files that had cost data. Here’s how many reasons it found clear and reasonable, by the five-year cost gap [1].

Five-year cost gap to the cheapest loanReasons with no concerns
Less than $1,00074.1%
$1,000 to $5,00066.8%
$5,000 to $20,00045.4%
More than $20,00034.1%

The bigger the gap, the fewer reasons were clear.

Those grades measure how well the reason was written down. ASIC said a bigger cost gap can still suit the borrower. It also said brokers did not appear to favour lenders that paid a higher commission [1].

The five-year, two-number check

Every loan on my shortlist gets two numbers.

The first is what it costs over five years, the window ASIC used.

The second is how much that lender will lend you.

For a business owner, the second number moves a long way. Some lenders average your last two years of tax returns. That pulls a growing business backwards. Some take your latest year. One lender adds back the depreciation on your truck. Another doesn’t.

A worked example, in round numbers

These are round numbers, made up for the example.

Say you need $700,000 for a new build. One lender is 0.30% a year cheaper.

Priced on the full $700,000, that saves about $2,100 a year. Over five years it’s about $10,500.

Now the second number. The cheaper lender averages your two years and lends $620,000. A lender that takes your latest year lends $760,000.

The cheaper loan leaves you $80,000 short of the house. The dearer one buys it.

Cheaper-rate lenderLatest-year lender
Rate difference0.30% a year lower
Five-year saving on $700,000about $10,500
What the lender will lend$620,000$760,000
Against the $700,000 you need$80,000 shortcovered

ASIC put a $10,500 gap in its $5,000 to $20,000 group. In that group, fewer than half the written reasons were clear of concerns.

So the reason has to be written down plainly. On my files, that $10,500 is recorded as the price of a purchase that settles. If your accountant asks why you paid more, that’s your sentence.

How an offset account can tip the sum

An offset account is a savings account linked to the loan. Every dollar in it cuts the interest, dollar for dollar.

Say only the dearer loan has one. You park a $60,000 business buffer in that offset. At 6.3% a year, it saves about $3,780 a year in interest.

That’s more than the $2,100 the cheaper rate saves.

The rate looked like the deal. The features were the deal.

When the cheapest loan wins

Sometimes the cheapest loan wins on both numbers. Then it’s the right call, and the file should say so.

On one file this year, the lender with the lowest total charges also offered ten years of interest-only repayments. Interest-only means you pay just the interest for a set time. The rest of the panel offered three to five years.

That loan won on cost and on fit. The file records why.

Who this check matters most for

Four kinds of borrower need it most.

Business owners, whose income reads differently lender to lender.

Tradies, whose equipment and vehicle finance changes the sum.

Anyone who changed their business structure in the last two years.

Land-and-build buyers, who need the full amount to finish the house.

On a steady wage with plenty of room, the cheapest loan that meets your needs is usually the right one. I’ll say so.

What to ask your broker this week

Ask for the two numbers on each loan they shortlisted. The five-year cost, and how much each lender would lend.

Then ask for the written reason your loan won.

If the numbers and the reason line up, good. If the reason could belong to anyone, or your business and property loans were priced on their own, it’s worth a second look.

New-build homes are part of what I sell. So it’s fair to ask whether a paid hour with me is a sales pitch. The interest-only file above is my answer. When the cheapest loan is right, the file says so.

Questions people ask about the cheapest home loan

What is ASIC Report 840?

It’s ASIC’s review of how mortgage brokers meet the best interests duty, released on 13 October 2026. ASIC looked at 1,600 loan recommendations from 13 credit licensees in eight large aggregator groups. It compared loan costs over a five-year window.

Is the cheapest home loan rate always the best loan?

Often, but not always. A cheaper rate can come with a lower borrowing amount or missing features like an offset account. ASIC’s own test was the lowest cost for given features, so the loan has to fit your needs first.

Why did ASIC measure loan costs over five years?

Five years is closer to how long people keep a loan before they sell or refinance. ASIC divided 30-year loan costs by six to put every loan on the same five-year clock.

Can a broker recommend a loan that costs more?

Yes, if it’s in your best interests and the reason is recorded. ASIC said a bigger cost gap can still suit the borrower. In its review, the bigger the five-year cost gap, the fewer written reasons were clear of concerns.

Why do lenders lend different amounts on the same income?

Each lender has its own policy for reading income. For self-employed borrowers, some average two years of tax returns and some use the latest year. Some add back costs like depreciation. The same figures can give very different borrowing amounts.

Does an offset account make a dearer loan cheaper?

It can. Money in an offset account cuts the interest charged, dollar for dollar. A $60,000 balance at 6.3% saves about $3,780 a year, which can outweigh a small rate difference.

If you’d like your shortlist checked against both numbers, book a time at AeFin.as.me and bring the figures.

My book, Structure Beats Prediction, sets out the thinking at aefin.com.au/structure-beats-prediction.

(This is general information only. It does not take your personal situation into account. Tax and suitability belong with your own accountant. Any credit is subject to lender assessment and approval. My interest: I’m a mortgage broker, I’m paid by lenders when I arrange a loan, and this article links to my booking page.)

Juan Jeffery

Sources

  1. Australian Securities and Investments Commission, Report 840, published 13 October 2026, and media release 26-240MR (13 credit licensees, eight aggregator groups, about two-thirds of broker representatives, 1,600 loan recommendations, 1 April 2023 to 31 March 2025, 30-year costs divided by six, seven of eight groups reporting more than 20%, quoted reasons, Tables 3 and 4, 551 files, commission finding, “lowest available cost for given features”).
  2. National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009, Part 3-5A, sections 158LA and 158LE (best interests duty for mortgage brokers, in force from 1 January 2021), and ASIC, Regulatory Guide 273 Mortgage brokers: Best interests duty, 24 June 2020.

Calculated figures ($2,100 a year, $10,500 over five years, the $80,000 shortfall, $3,780 of offset interest) are the author’s own arithmetic. The rate gap, loan amounts and 6.3% rate are round illustrations, not quotes or a client’s figures. Lender income policies are described in general terms and differ by lender.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *